Skip to content
20% off Everything for November and December
Free Shipping in the United States

NEED HELP?716-633-3738
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

5

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 1
  • Toggle website search
1 Menu Close
“Red Twinkle In The Night” has been added to your cart. View cart
  • View:
  • 12
  • 24
  • All
  • A Floral MotifA Floral Motif Quick View
    • A Floral MotifA Floral Motif Quick View

    • A Floral Motif

    • $785.00 $628.00
    • Add to cart
  • A Sapphire Blue DevotionA Sapphire Blue Devotion Quick View
    • A Sapphire Blue DevotionA Sapphire Blue Devotion Quick View

    • A Sapphire Blue Devotion

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • A Treasure HuntA Treasure Hunt Quick View
    • A Treasure HuntA Treasure Hunt Quick View

    • A Treasure Hunt

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Allison StudioAllison Studio Quick View
    • Allison StudioAllison Studio Quick View

    • Allison Studio

    • $225.00 $180.00
    • Add to cart
  • Angel Winged HeartAngel Winged Heart Quick View
    • Angel Winged HeartAngel Winged Heart Quick View

    • Angel Winged Heart

    • $1,950.00 $1,560.00
    • Add to cart
  • Baby BullBaby Bull Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Baby BullBaby Bull Quick View

    • Baby Bull

    • $435.00 $348.00
    • Read more
  • Barbara Bixby LariatBarbara Bixby Lariat Quick View
    • Barbara Bixby LariatBarbara Bixby Lariat Quick View

    • Barbara Bixby Lariat

    • $195.00 $156.00
    • Add to cart
  • Be MineBe Mine Quick View
    • Be MineBe Mine Quick View

    • Be Mine

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Bell Caped BeautyBell Caped Beauty Quick View
    • Bell Caped BeautyBell Caped Beauty Quick View

    • Bell Caped Beauty

    • $335.00 $268.00
    • Add to cart
  • Belle of The BallBelle of The Ball Quick View
    • Belle of The BallBelle of The Ball Quick View

    • Belle of The Ball

    • $195.00 $156.00
    • Add to cart
  • Bewitched With LoveBewitched With Love Quick View
    • Bewitched With LoveBewitched With Love Quick View

    • Bewitched With Love

    • $535.00 $428.00
    • Add to cart
  • Big Bold and BeautifulBig Bold and Beautiful Quick View
    • Big Bold and BeautifulBig Bold and Beautiful Quick View

    • Big Bold and Beautiful

    • $450.00 $360.00
    • Add to cart
  • Big Love Big Heart’s PartnerBig Love Big Heart’s Partner Quick View
    • Big Love Big Heart’s PartnerBig Love Big Heart’s Partner Quick View

    • Big Love Big Heart’s Partner

    • $9,000.00 $7,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Black BeautyBlack Beauty Quick View
    • Black BeautyBlack Beauty Quick View

    • Black Beauty

    • $575.00 $460.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue TearBlue Tear Quick View
    • Blue TearBlue Tear Quick View

    • Blue Tear

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Calvin Begay Pueblo Inlay SetCalvin Begay Pueblo Inlay Set Quick View
    • Calvin Begay Pueblo Inlay SetCalvin Begay Pueblo Inlay Set Quick View

    • Calvin Begay Pueblo Inlay Set

    • $800.00 $640.00
    • Add to cart
  • Chevron Color ComboChevron Color Combo Quick View
    • Chevron Color ComboChevron Color Combo Quick View

    • Chevron Color Combo

    • $1,100.00 $880.00
    • Add to cart
  • Cool BlueCool Blue Quick View
    • Cool BlueCool Blue Quick View

    • Cool Blue

    • $435.00 $348.00
    • Add to cart
  • Daisy DoDaisy Do Quick View
    • Daisy DoDaisy Do Quick View

    • Daisy Do

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • Day and Night DelightDay and Night Delight Quick View
    • Day and Night DelightDay and Night Delight Quick View

    • Day and Night Delight

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Deco Locket Of LoveDeco Locket Of Love Quick View
    • Deco Locket Of LoveDeco Locket Of Love Quick View

    • Deco Locket Of Love

    • $165.00 $132.00
    • Add to cart
  • DeliaDelia Quick View
    • DeliaDelia Quick View

    • Delia

    • $265.00 $212.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond By Yard HeadlightsDiamond By Yard Headlights Quick View
    • Diamond By Yard HeadlightsDiamond By Yard Headlights Quick View

    • Diamond By Yard Headlights

    • $1,900.00 $1,520.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond CenterpieceDiamond Centerpiece Quick View
    • Diamond CenterpieceDiamond Centerpiece Quick View

    • Diamond Centerpiece

    • $925.00 $740.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond LifesaverDiamond Lifesaver Quick View
    • Diamond LifesaverDiamond Lifesaver Quick View

    • Diamond Lifesaver

    • $525.00 $420.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond Step LadderDiamond Step Ladder Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Diamond Step LadderDiamond Step Ladder Quick View

    • Diamond Step Ladder

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Read more
  • Divinity SymbolDivinity Symbol Quick View
    • Divinity SymbolDivinity Symbol Quick View

    • Divinity Symbol

    • $195.00 $156.00
    • Add to cart
  • Earthly BeautyEarthly Beauty Quick View
    • Earthly BeautyEarthly Beauty Quick View

    • Earthly Beauty

    • $925.00 $740.00
    • Add to cart
  • Faithful Emerald DevotionFaithful Emerald Devotion Quick View
    • Faithful Emerald DevotionFaithful Emerald Devotion Quick View

    • Faithful Emerald Devotion

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Fantasy DreamsFantasy Dreams Quick View
    • Fantasy DreamsFantasy Dreams Quick View

    • Fantasy Dreams

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Fiery Hot AirFiery Hot Air Quick View
    • Fiery Hot AirFiery Hot Air Quick View

    • Fiery Hot Air

    • $145.00 $116.00
    • Add to cart
  • Figaro It isFigaro It is Quick View
    • Figaro It isFigaro It is Quick View

    • Figaro It is

    • $125.00 $100.00
    • Add to cart
  • Fire and Earth EssenceFire and Earth Essence Quick View
    • Fire and Earth EssenceFire and Earth Essence Quick View

    • Fire and Earth Essence

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Add to cart
  • Flashing Rainbow of ColorFlashing Rainbow of Color Quick View
    • Flashing Rainbow of ColorFlashing Rainbow of Color Quick View

    • Flashing Rainbow of Color

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Add to cart
  • Floating LanternsFloating Lanterns Quick View
    • Floating LanternsFloating Lanterns Quick View

    • Floating Lanterns

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Foxy TopazFoxy Topaz Quick View
    • Foxy TopazFoxy Topaz Quick View

    • Foxy Topaz

    • $95.00 $76.00
    • Add to cart
  • Free Form StarFree Form Star Quick View
    • Free Form StarFree Form Star Quick View

    • Free Form Star

    • $725.00 $580.00
    • Add to cart
  • Golden RoyaltyGolden Royalty Quick View
    • Golden RoyaltyGolden Royalty Quick View

    • Golden Royalty

    • $1,450.00 $1,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Harmony and Spiritual GuidanceHarmony and Spiritual Guidance Quick View
    • Harmony and Spiritual GuidanceHarmony and Spiritual Guidance Quick View

    • Harmony and Spiritual Guidance

    • $350.00 $280.00
    • Add to cart
  • Heart EmbraceHeart Embrace Quick View
    • Heart EmbraceHeart Embrace Quick View

    • Heart Embrace

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Heart of LoveHeart of Love Quick View
    • Heart of LoveHeart of Love Quick View

    • Heart of Love

    • $335.00 $268.00
    • Add to cart
  • Hearts and Flowers Oh MyHearts and Flowers Oh My Quick View
    • Hearts and Flowers Oh MyHearts and Flowers Oh My Quick View

    • Hearts and Flowers Oh My

    • $78.00 $62.40
    • Add to cart
  • Hearts DesireHearts Desire Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Hearts DesireHearts Desire Quick View

    • Hearts Desire

    • $850.00 $680.00
    • Read more
  • Here Kitty KittyHere Kitty Kitty Quick View
    • Here Kitty KittyHere Kitty Kitty Quick View

    • Here Kitty Kitty

    • $535.00 $428.00
    • Add to cart
  • HoneyHoney Quick View
    • HoneyHoney Quick View

    • Honey

    • $185.00 $148.00
    • Add to cart
  • Illmiunating OrbIllmiunating Orb Quick View
    • Illmiunating OrbIllmiunating Orb Quick View

    • Illmiunating Orb

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Inca RoseInca Rose Quick View
    • Inca RoseInca Rose Quick View

    • Inca Rose

    • $150.00 $120.00
    • Add to cart
  • Israeli DesignIsraeli Design Quick View
    • Israeli DesignIsraeli Design Quick View

    • Israeli Design

    • $110.00 $88.00
    • Add to cart
  • Jade All The WayJade All The Way Quick View
    • Jade All The WayJade All The Way Quick View

    • Jade All The Way

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Jade BeadsJade Beads Quick View
    • Jade BeadsJade Beads Quick View

    • Jade Beads

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Jittery HeartJittery Heart Quick View
    • Jittery HeartJittery Heart Quick View

    • Jittery Heart

    • $875.00 $700.00
    • Add to cart
  • Judith Ripka OvalsJudith Ripka Ovals Quick View
    • Judith Ripka OvalsJudith Ripka Ovals Quick View

    • Judith Ripka Ovals

    • $125.00 $100.00
    • Add to cart
  • Lady OpheliaLady Ophelia Quick View
    • Lady OpheliaLady Ophelia Quick View

    • Lady Ophelia

    • $210.00 $168.00
    • Add to cart
  • Lake Biwa BeautiesLake Biwa Beauties Quick View
    • Lake Biwa BeautiesLake Biwa Beauties Quick View

    • Lake Biwa Beauties

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Literally Cross Your HeartLiterally Cross Your Heart Quick View
    • Literally Cross Your HeartLiterally Cross Your Heart Quick View

    • Literally Cross Your Heart

    • $125.00 $100.00
    • Add to cart
  • Love LetterLove Letter Quick View
    • Love LetterLove Letter Quick View

    • Love Letter

    • $95.00 $76.00
    • Add to cart
  • Lucky CharmLucky Charm Quick View
    • Lucky CharmLucky Charm Quick View

    • Lucky Charm

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Magic Stallion WandMagic Stallion Wand Quick View
    • Magic Stallion WandMagic Stallion Wand Quick View

    • Magic Stallion Wand

    • $195.00 $156.00
    • Add to cart
  • MazeMaze Quick View
    • MazeMaze Quick View

    • Maze

    • $65.00 $52.00
    • Add to cart
  • My Fair LadyMy Fair Lady Quick View
    • My Fair LadyMy Fair Lady Quick View

    • My Fair Lady

    • $1,495.00 $1,196.00
    • Add to cart
  • My HonorMy Honor Quick View
    • My HonorMy Honor Quick View

    • My Honor

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mystical CardioidMystical Cardioid Quick View
    • Mystical CardioidMystical Cardioid Quick View

    • Mystical Cardioid

    • $85.00 $68.00
    • Add to cart
  • Opal FloraOpal Flora Quick View
    • Opal FloraOpal Flora Quick View

    • Opal Flora

    • $675.00 $540.00
    • Add to cart
  • Paint Me A ….Paint Me A …. Quick View
    • Paint Me A ….Paint Me A …. Quick View

    • Paint Me A ….

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Passion and VitalityPassion and Vitality Quick View
    • Passion and VitalityPassion and Vitality Quick View

    • Passion and Vitality

    • $335.00 $268.00
    • Add to cart
  • Petite Diamond By Yard HeadlightsPetite Diamond By Yard Headlights Quick View
    • Petite Diamond By Yard HeadlightsPetite Diamond By Yard Headlights Quick View

    • Petite Diamond By Yard Headlights

    • $1,800.00 $1,440.00
    • Add to cart
  • Positive EnergyPositive Energy Quick View
    • Positive EnergyPositive Energy Quick View

    • Positive Energy

    • $400.00 $320.00
    • Add to cart
  • Protection and HealingProtection and Healing Quick View
    • Protection and HealingProtection and Healing Quick View

    • Protection and Healing

    • $95.00 $76.00
    • Add to cart
  • Purple BaublesPurple Baubles Quick View
    • Purple BaublesPurple Baubles Quick View

    • Purple Baubles

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Purple WishbonePurple Wishbone Quick View
    • Purple WishbonePurple Wishbone Quick View

    • Purple Wishbone

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Rays Of SunlightRays Of Sunlight Quick View
    • Rays Of SunlightRays Of Sunlight Quick View

    • Rays Of Sunlight

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red Twinkle In The NightRed Twinkle In The Night Quick View
    • Red Twinkle In The NightRed Twinkle In The Night Quick View

    • Red Twinkle In The Night

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby DearRuby Dear Quick View
    • Ruby DearRuby Dear Quick View

    • Ruby Dear

    • $525.00 $420.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby FashionRuby Fashion Quick View
    • Ruby FashionRuby Fashion Quick View

    • Ruby Fashion

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby Red LoveRuby Red Love Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Ruby Red LoveRuby Red Love Quick View

    • Ruby Red Love

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • Russian RoublesRussian Roubles Quick View
    • Russian RoublesRussian Roubles Quick View

    • Russian Roubles

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Russian SymbolismRussian Symbolism Quick View
    • Russian SymbolismRussian Symbolism Quick View

    • Russian Symbolism

    • $185.00 $148.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sagittarius It IsSagittarius It Is Quick View
    • Sagittarius It IsSagittarius It Is Quick View

    • Sagittarius It Is

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sea TranquilitySea Tranquility Quick View
    • Sea TranquilitySea Tranquility Quick View

    • Sea Tranquility

    • $199.00 $159.20
    • Add to cart
  • Seven Years Of BlissSeven Years Of Bliss Quick View
    • Seven Years Of BlissSeven Years Of Bliss Quick View

    • Seven Years Of Bliss

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sky, Earth and SeaSky, Earth and Sea Quick View
    • Sky, Earth and SeaSky, Earth and Sea Quick View

    • Sky, Earth and Sea

    • $235.00 $188.00
    • Add to cart
  • Spiga LikeSpiga Like Quick View
    • Spiga LikeSpiga Like Quick View

    • Spiga Like

    • $210.00 $168.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sterling Silver MacaroniSterling Silver Macaroni Quick View
    • Sterling Silver MacaroniSterling Silver Macaroni Quick View

    • Sterling Silver Macaroni

    • $225.00 $180.00
    • Add to cart
  • Stone of Mother GaiaStone of Mother Gaia Quick View
    • Stone of Mother GaiaStone of Mother Gaia Quick View

    • Stone of Mother Gaia

    • $275.00 $220.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sunset HuesSunset Hues Quick View
    • Sunset HuesSunset Hues Quick View

    • Sunset Hues

    • $85.00 $68.00
    • Add to cart
  • Teardrop QueenTeardrop Queen Quick View
    • Teardrop QueenTeardrop Queen Quick View

    • Teardrop Queen

    • $1,300.00 $1,040.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tears and DropletsTears and Droplets Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Tears and DropletsTears and Droplets Quick View

    • Tears and Droplets

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Read more
  • The Ceven SetThe Ceven Set Quick View
    • The Ceven SetThe Ceven Set Quick View

    • The Ceven Set

    • $1,350.00 $1,080.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Crown and The TeardropThe Crown and The Teardrop Quick View
    • The Crown and The TeardropThe Crown and The Teardrop Quick View

    • The Crown and The Teardrop

    • $550.00 $440.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Diamond LanternThe Diamond Lantern Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      The Diamond LanternThe Diamond Lantern Quick View

    • The Diamond Lantern

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Read more
  • The Diamond PyramidThe Diamond Pyramid Quick View
    • The Diamond PyramidThe Diamond Pyramid Quick View

    • The Diamond Pyramid

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Effy BluesThe Effy Blues Quick View
    • The Effy BluesThe Effy Blues Quick View

    • The Effy Blues

    • $225.00 $180.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Forever BondThe Forever Bond Quick View
    • The Forever BondThe Forever Bond Quick View

    • The Forever Bond

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Opal FanThe Opal Fan Quick View
    • The Opal FanThe Opal Fan Quick View

    • The Opal Fan

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • The ProtectorThe Protector Quick View
    • The ProtectorThe Protector Quick View

    • The Protector

    • $275.00 $220.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Real Deal-JadeThe Real Deal-Jade Quick View
    • The Real Deal-JadeThe Real Deal-Jade Quick View

    • The Real Deal-Jade

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Seven Year JourneyThe Seven Year Journey Quick View
    • The Seven Year JourneyThe Seven Year Journey Quick View

    • The Seven Year Journey

    • $375.00 $300.00
    • Add to cart
  • The ViewThe View Quick View
    • The ViewThe View Quick View

    • The View

    • $900.00 $720.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three Natural BeautiesThree Natural Beauties Quick View
    • Three Natural BeautiesThree Natural Beauties Quick View

    • Three Natural Beauties

    • $150.00 $120.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tiffany LifesaverTiffany Lifesaver Quick View
    • Tiffany LifesaverTiffany Lifesaver Quick View

    • Tiffany Lifesaver

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tiny Heart Big LoveTiny Heart Big Love Quick View
    • Tiny Heart Big LoveTiny Heart Big Love Quick View

    • Tiny Heart Big Love

    • $315.00 $252.00
    • Add to cart
  • TransformationTransformation Quick View
    • TransformationTransformation Quick View

    • Transformation

    • $78.00 $62.40
    • Add to cart
  • Vertical Trilogy LifelineVertical Trilogy Lifeline Quick View
    • Vertical Trilogy LifelineVertical Trilogy Lifeline Quick View

    • Vertical Trilogy Lifeline

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Win Me OverWin Me Over Quick View
    • Win Me OverWin Me Over Quick View

    • Win Me Over

    • $145.00 $116.00
    • Add to cart
  • WisdomWisdom Quick View
    • WisdomWisdom Quick View

    • Wisdom

    • $125.00 $100.00
    • Add to cart

Search

Filter by price

Price: —

Product categories

  • Categories: This is how users will find your products on your site
  • Engagement and Wedding
    • Diamond Rings
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Wedding Bands
  • Era
    • Art Deco
    • Art Nouveau
    • Edwardian
    • Estate
    • Midcentury
    • Retro
    • Victorian
  • Merchandise
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Ladies Vanity Items
    • Men's Jewelry
      • Rings
    • Necklaces
    • Pins
    • Rings
      • Diamond Rings
      • Gemstone Rings
    • Silver Jewelry
  • Other

Cart

Facebook-f Instagram Pinterest

Join Our Newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Navigation

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us

Information

Address:
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

Phone:
716-633-3738

Email: sarahs_jewelry@verizon.net

Hours
Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

Open Sunday and Monday before Christmas 11-4pm
Open Christmas Eve 11-3pm
SecurityMetrics Credit Card Safe

Maps

Images provided on this website are for personal, non-commercial use. Republication, retransmission, or reproduction of such images is strictly prohibited.
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 1
  • Toggle website search
Type your search
×
×

Cart