Skip to content
Free Shipping in the United States

NEED HELP?716-633-3738
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

5

May Sale 20% off Everything

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY

Hours:

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 1
  • Toggle website search
1 Menu Close
“Big Love Big Heart” has been added to your cart. View cart
  • View:
  • 12
  • 24
  • All
  • A Heart Of GoldA Heart Of Gold Quick View
    • A Heart Of GoldA Heart Of Gold Quick View

    • A Heart Of Gold

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • A Transmutation BeautyA Transmutation Beauty Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      A Transmutation BeautyA Transmutation Beauty Quick View

    • A Transmutation Beauty

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Read more
  • All In OneAll In One Quick View
    • All In OneAll In One Quick View

    • All In One

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • An Old FlameAn Old Flame Quick View
    • An Old FlameAn Old Flame Quick View

    • An Old Flame

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Art Deco HeadlightArt Deco Headlight Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Art Deco HeadlightArt Deco Headlight Quick View

    • Art Deco Headlight

    • $4,500.00 $3,600.00
    • Read more
  • Be My PrincessBe My Princess Quick View
    • Be My PrincessBe My Princess Quick View

    • Be My Princess

    • $5,200.00 $4,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Big Love Big HeartBig Love Big Heart Quick View
    • Big Love Big HeartBig Love Big Heart Quick View

    • Big Love Big Heart

    • $3,800.00 $3,040.00
    • Add to cart
  • Black HoneycombBlack Honeycomb Quick View
    • Black HoneycombBlack Honeycomb Quick View

    • Black Honeycomb

    • $110.00 $88.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue and White DomeBlue and White Dome Quick View
    • Blue and White DomeBlue and White Dome Quick View

    • Blue and White Dome

    • $1,100.00 $880.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue HurricaneBlue Hurricane Quick View
    • Blue HurricaneBlue Hurricane Quick View

    • Blue Hurricane

    • $1,995.00 $1,596.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue NestBlue Nest Quick View
    • Blue NestBlue Nest Quick View

    • Blue Nest

    • $950.00 $760.00
    • Add to cart
  • BoldnessBoldness Quick View
    • BoldnessBoldness Quick View

    • Boldness

    • $200.00 $160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Buckle Up ButtercupBuckle Up Buttercup Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Buckle Up ButtercupBuckle Up Buttercup Quick View

    • Buckle Up Buttercup

    • $1,650.00 $1,320.00
    • Read more
  • Celery GreenCelery Green Quick View
    • Celery GreenCelery Green Quick View

    • Celery Green

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Charming Deco 1Charming Deco 1 Quick View
    • Charming Deco 1Charming Deco 1 Quick View

    • Charming Deco 1

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • CheerfulCheerful Quick View
    • CheerfulCheerful Quick View

    • Cheerful

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Colors of The RianbowColors of The Rianbow Quick View
    • Colors of The RianbowColors of The Rianbow Quick View

    • Colors of The Rianbow

    • $825.00 $660.00
    • Add to cart
  • David Yurman RedDavid Yurman Red Quick View
    • David Yurman RedDavid Yurman Red Quick View

    • David Yurman Red

    • $2,900.00 $2,320.00
    • Add to cart
  • Deco ClusterDeco Cluster Quick View
    • Deco ClusterDeco Cluster Quick View

    • Deco Cluster

    • $3,450.00 $2,760.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond DuoDiamond Duo Quick View
    • Diamond DuoDiamond Duo Quick View

    • Diamond Duo

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond PlumeDiamond Plume Quick View
    • Diamond PlumeDiamond Plume Quick View

    • Diamond Plume

    • $1,450.00 $1,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond Rings Around The RainbowDiamond Rings Around The Rainbow Quick View
    • Diamond Rings Around The RainbowDiamond Rings Around The Rainbow Quick View

    • Diamond Rings Around The Rainbow

    • $3,900.00 $3,120.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond SunburstDiamond Sunburst Quick View
    • Diamond SunburstDiamond Sunburst Quick View

    • Diamond Sunburst

    • $6,400.00 $5,120.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond TimelineDiamond Timeline Quick View
    • Diamond TimelineDiamond Timeline Quick View

    • Diamond Timeline

    • $7,500.00 $6,000.00
    • Add to cart
  • Diamond WaterfallDiamond Waterfall Quick View
    • Diamond WaterfallDiamond Waterfall Quick View

    • Diamond Waterfall

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • Divine Like DecoDivine Like Deco Quick View
    • Divine Like DecoDivine Like Deco Quick View

    • Divine Like Deco

    • $2,100.00 $1,680.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double DeckerDouble Decker Quick View
    • Double DeckerDouble Decker Quick View

    • Double Decker

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double Duty VowsDouble Duty Vows Quick View
    • Double Duty VowsDouble Duty Vows Quick View

    • Double Duty Vows

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double The BlissDouble The Bliss Quick View
    • Double The BlissDouble The Bliss Quick View

    • Double The Bliss

    • $950.00 $760.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double VisionDouble Vision Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Double VisionDouble Vision Quick View

    • Double Vision

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • Dreaming OfDreaming Of Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Dreaming OfDreaming Of Quick View

    • Dreaming Of

    • $1,100.00 $880.00
    • Read more
  • Edwardian BeautyEdwardian Beauty Quick View
    • Edwardian BeautyEdwardian Beauty Quick View

    • Edwardian Beauty

    • Read more
  • Egyptian SunsetEgyptian Sunset Quick View
    • Egyptian SunsetEgyptian Sunset Quick View

    • Egyptian Sunset

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • February BirthstoneFebruary Birthstone Quick View
    • February BirthstoneFebruary Birthstone Quick View

    • February Birthstone

    • $475.00 $380.00
    • Add to cart
  • Feminine LadyFeminine Lady Quick View
    • Feminine LadyFeminine Lady Quick View

    • Feminine Lady

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Fiery EnergyFiery Energy Quick View
    • Fiery EnergyFiery Energy Quick View

    • Fiery Energy

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Figure Eight ShineFigure Eight Shine Quick View
    • Figure Eight ShineFigure Eight Shine Quick View

    • Figure Eight Shine

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Finger CuffFinger Cuff Quick View
    • Finger CuffFinger Cuff Quick View

    • Finger Cuff

    • $125.00 $100.00
    • Add to cart
  • Floral BouquetFloral Bouquet Quick View
    • Floral BouquetFloral Bouquet Quick View

    • Floral Bouquet

    • $2,500.00 $2,000.00
    • Add to cart
  • Golden Age BeautyGolden Age Beauty Quick View
    • Golden Age BeautyGolden Age Beauty Quick View

    • Golden Age Beauty

    • Read more
  • Good LuckGood Luck Quick View
    • Good LuckGood Luck Quick View

    • Good Luck

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Happy SignetHappy Signet Quick View
    • Happy SignetHappy Signet Quick View

    • Happy Signet

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Add to cart
  • Happy TrioHappy Trio Quick View
    • Happy TrioHappy Trio Quick View

    • Happy Trio

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Heart and AngelsHeart and Angels Quick View
    • Heart and AngelsHeart and Angels Quick View

    • Heart and Angels

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Heart HaloHeart Halo Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Heart HaloHeart Halo Quick View

    • Heart Halo

    • $750.00 $600.00
    • Read more
  • I Love YouI Love You Quick View
    • I Love YouI Love You Quick View

    • I Love You

    • $8,900.00 $7,120.00
    • Add to cart
  • Inner FireInner Fire Quick View
    • Inner FireInner Fire Quick View

    • Inner Fire

    • $1,150.00 $920.00
    • Add to cart
  • January BabyJanuary Baby Quick View
    • January BabyJanuary Baby Quick View

    • January Baby

    • $245.00 $196.00
    • Add to cart
  • Kindling SpiritKindling Spirit Quick View
    • Kindling SpiritKindling Spirit Quick View

    • Kindling Spirit

    • $2,250.00 $1,800.00
    • Add to cart
  • LifebloodLifeblood Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      LifebloodLifeblood Quick View

    • Lifeblood

    • $315.00 $252.00
    • Read more
  • Lighting Up The SkyLighting Up The Sky Quick View
    • Lighting Up The SkyLighting Up The Sky Quick View

    • Lighting Up The Sky

    • $2,950.00 $2,360.00
    • Add to cart
  • Love and CompassionLove and Compassion Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Love and CompassionLove and Compassion Quick View

    • Love and Compassion

    • $525.00 $420.00
    • Read more
  • Lover’s CrossroadsLover’s Crossroads Quick View
    • Lover’s CrossroadsLover’s Crossroads Quick View

    • Lover’s Crossroads

    • $6,500.00 $5,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Lucky Five WrapLucky Five Wrap Quick View
    • Lucky Five WrapLucky Five Wrap Quick View

    • Lucky Five Wrap

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mid Century I DoMid Century I Do Quick View
    • Mid Century I DoMid Century I Do Quick View

    • Mid Century I Do

    • $1,075.00 $860.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mid Century PlatinumMid Century Platinum Quick View
    • Mid Century PlatinumMid Century Platinum Quick View

    • Mid Century Platinum

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • My Pretty DragonMy Pretty Dragon Quick View
    • My Pretty DragonMy Pretty Dragon Quick View

    • My Pretty Dragon

    • $330.00 $264.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mysterious PodMysterious Pod Quick View
    • Mysterious PodMysterious Pod Quick View

    • Mysterious Pod

    • $435.00 $348.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mystery and Magic’s PartnerMystery and Magic’s Partner Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Mystery and Magic’s PartnerMystery and Magic’s Partner Quick View

    • Mystery and Magic’s Partner

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • Mystical AllureMystical Allure Quick View
    • Mystical AllureMystical Allure Quick View

    • Mystical Allure

    • $3,950.00 $3,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Oceanic ViewOceanic View Quick View
    • Oceanic ViewOceanic View Quick View

    • Oceanic View

    • $78.00 $62.40
    • Add to cart
  • Olive GreenOlive Green Quick View
    • Olive GreenOlive Green Quick View

    • Olive Green

    • $925.00 $740.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ornate BambooOrnate Bamboo Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Ornate BambooOrnate Bamboo Quick View

    • Ornate Bamboo

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • Petite FlowerPetite Flower Quick View
    • Petite FlowerPetite Flower Quick View

    • Petite Flower

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Picture PerfectPicture Perfect Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Picture PerfectPicture Perfect Quick View

    • Picture Perfect

    • $585.00 $468.00
    • Read more
  • PrismaticPrismatic Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      PrismaticPrismatic Quick View

    • Prismatic

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Read more
  • Protect MeProtect Me Quick View
    • Protect MeProtect Me Quick View

    • Protect Me

    • $1,000.00 $800.00
    • Add to cart
  • Purple DesirePurple Desire Quick View
    • Purple DesirePurple Desire Quick View

    • Purple Desire

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Raspberry DelightRaspberry Delight Quick View
    • Raspberry DelightRaspberry Delight Quick View

    • Raspberry Delight

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Reach ForReach For Quick View
    • Reach ForReach For Quick View

    • Reach For

    • $1,495.00 $1,196.00
    • Add to cart
  • Rebecca Norman DesignRebecca Norman Design Quick View
    • Rebecca Norman DesignRebecca Norman Design Quick View

    • Rebecca Norman Design

    • $195.00 $156.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red and White AffairRed and White Affair Quick View
    • Red and White AffairRed and White Affair Quick View

    • Red and White Affair

    • $1,450.00 $1,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red and White Gemstone DelightRed and White Gemstone Delight Quick View
    • Red and White Gemstone DelightRed and White Gemstone Delight Quick View

    • Red and White Gemstone Delight

    • $6,200.00 $4,960.00
    • Add to cart
  • Robin Egg DelightRobin Egg Delight Quick View
    • Robin Egg DelightRobin Egg Delight Quick View

    • Robin Egg Delight

    • $2,950.00 $2,360.00
    • Add to cart
  • Rose Are PinkRose Are Pink Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Rose Are PinkRose Are Pink Quick View

    • Rose Are Pink

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • Ruby Red FlashRuby Red Flash Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Ruby Red FlashRuby Red Flash Quick View

    • Ruby Red Flash

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Read more
  • Ruby SlipperRuby Slipper Quick View
    • Ruby SlipperRuby Slipper Quick View

    • Ruby Slipper

    • $12,000.00 $9,600.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby TearRuby Tear Quick View
    • Ruby TearRuby Tear Quick View

    • Ruby Tear

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Russian BeautyRussian Beauty Quick View
    • Russian BeautyRussian Beauty Quick View

    • Russian Beauty

    • $2,950.00 $2,360.00
    • Add to cart
  • Sherlock MysterySherlock Mystery Quick View
    • Sherlock MysterySherlock Mystery Quick View

    • Sherlock Mystery

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • Snaking AroundSnaking Around Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Snaking AroundSnaking Around Quick View

    • Snaking Around

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Read more
  • Sparkly TunnelSparkly Tunnel Quick View
    • Sparkly TunnelSparkly Tunnel Quick View

    • Sparkly Tunnel

    • $900.00 $720.00
    • Add to cart
  • Squaring the CircleSquaring the Circle Quick View
    • Squaring the CircleSquaring the Circle Quick View

    • Squaring the Circle

    • $650.00 $520.00
    • Add to cart
  • Strength and ResilienceStrength and Resilience Quick View
    • Strength and ResilienceStrength and Resilience Quick View

    • Strength and Resilience

    • $1,450.00 $1,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ten Year BlissTen Year Bliss Quick View
    • Ten Year BlissTen Year Bliss Quick View

    • Ten Year Bliss

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • The BeamerThe Beamer Quick View
    • The BeamerThe Beamer Quick View

    • The Beamer

    • Read more
  • The Earth and SkyThe Earth and Sky Quick View
    • The Earth and SkyThe Earth and Sky Quick View

    • The Earth and Sky

    • $4,200.00 $3,360.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Elongated TiaraThe Elongated Tiara Quick View
    • The Elongated TiaraThe Elongated Tiara Quick View

    • The Elongated Tiara

    • $1,150.00 $920.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Golden CycloneThe Golden Cyclone Quick View
    • The Golden CycloneThe Golden Cyclone Quick View

    • The Golden Cyclone

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • The IslandThe Island Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      The IslandThe Island Quick View

    • The Island

    • $315.00 $252.00
    • Read more
  • The Jewel Of KingsThe Jewel Of Kings Quick View
    • The Jewel Of KingsThe Jewel Of Kings Quick View

    • The Jewel Of Kings

    • Read more
  • The Looking GlassThe Looking Glass Quick View
    • The Looking GlassThe Looking Glass Quick View

    • The Looking Glass

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • The MeanderThe Meander Quick View
    • The MeanderThe Meander Quick View

    • The Meander

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Ruby ShieldThe Ruby Shield Quick View
    • The Ruby ShieldThe Ruby Shield Quick View

    • The Ruby Shield

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Sea CoastThe Sea Coast Quick View
    • The Sea CoastThe Sea Coast Quick View

    • The Sea Coast

    • $5,000.00 $4,000.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Soothing StoneThe Soothing Stone Quick View
    • The Soothing StoneThe Soothing Stone Quick View

    • The Soothing Stone

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • The TempleThe Temple Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      The TempleThe Temple Quick View

    • The Temple

    • $445.00 $356.00
    • Read more
  • The TiaraThe Tiara Quick View
    • The TiaraThe Tiara Quick View

    • The Tiara

    • $4,650.00 $3,720.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Violet ShieldThe Violet Shield Quick View
    • The Violet ShieldThe Violet Shield Quick View

    • The Violet Shield

    • $800.00 $640.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three AmigosThree Amigos Quick View
    • Three AmigosThree Amigos Quick View

    • Three Amigos

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three in OneThree in One Quick View
    • Three in OneThree in One Quick View

    • Three in One

    • $8,500.00 $6,800.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tony The TigerTony The Tiger Quick View
    • Tony The TigerTony The Tiger Quick View

    • Tony The Tiger

    • $78.00 $62.40
    • Add to cart
  • Twenty Three Years OfTwenty Three Years Of Quick View
    • Twenty Three Years OfTwenty Three Years Of Quick View

    • Twenty Three Years Of

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Two Tone BeautyTwo Tone Beauty Quick View
    • Two Tone BeautyTwo Tone Beauty Quick View

    • Two Tone Beauty

    • $2,500.00 $2,000.00
    • Add to cart
  • Victorian GentlemanVictorian Gentleman Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Victorian GentlemanVictorian Gentleman Quick View

    • Victorian Gentleman

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Read more
  • VioletViolet Quick View
    • VioletViolet Quick View

    • Violet

    • $2,385.00 $1,908.00
    • Add to cart
  • What is Your FortuneWhat is Your Fortune Quick View
    • What is Your FortuneWhat is Your Fortune Quick View

    • What is Your Fortune

    • $1,900.00 $1,520.00
    • Add to cart
  • Who Am IWho Am I Quick View
    • Who Am IWho Am I Quick View

    • Who Am I

    • $1,175.00 $940.00
    • Add to cart
  • Wing ItWing It Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Wing ItWing It Quick View

    • Wing It

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Read more
  • WisdomWisdom Quick View
    • WisdomWisdom Quick View

    • Wisdom

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Wrapped In loveWrapped In love Quick View
    • Wrapped In loveWrapped In love Quick View

    • Wrapped In love

    • $3,300.00 $2,640.00
    • Add to cart
  • X Marks the SpotX Marks the Spot Quick View
    • X Marks the SpotX Marks the Spot Quick View

    • X Marks the Spot

    • $500.00 $400.00
    • Add to cart
  • You Are My SunshineYou Are My Sunshine Quick View
    • You Are My SunshineYou Are My Sunshine Quick View

    • You Are My Sunshine

    • $4,200.00 $3,360.00
    • Add to cart

Search

Filter by price

Price: —

Product categories

  • Categories: This is how users will find your products on your site
  • Engagement and Wedding
    • Diamond Rings
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Wedding Bands
  • Era
    • Art Deco
    • Art Nouveau
    • Edwardian
    • Estate
    • Midcentury
    • Retro
    • Victorian
  • Merchandise
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Ladies Vanity Items
    • Men's Jewelry
      • Rings
    • Necklaces
    • Pins
    • Rings
      • Diamond Rings
      • Gemstone Rings
    • Silver Jewelry
  • Other

Cart

Facebook-f Instagram Pinterest

Join Our Newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Navigation

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us

Information

Address:
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

Phone:
716-633-3738

Email: sarahs_jewelry@verizon.net

Hours
Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

Open Sunday and Monday before Christmas 11-4pm
Open Christmas Eve 11-3pm
SecurityMetrics Credit Card Safe

Maps

Images provided on this website are for personal, non-commercial use. Republication, retransmission, or reproduction of such images is strictly prohibited.
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 1
  • Toggle website search
Type your search
×
×

Cart