Skip to content
Free Shipping in the United States

NEED HELP?716-633-3738
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

5

NEED HELP?716-633-3738
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

5

NEED HELP?
716-633-3738
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

5

Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm
20% Off Everything All
of November and December
final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY
Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm
20% Off Everything All
of November and December
final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY
Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm
20% Off Everything All of November and December
final logo 04 - Sarah's Vintage & Estate Jewelry in Williamsville, NY
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 0
  • Toggle website search
0 Menu Close
  • View:
  • 12
  • 24
  • All
  • A Flash of BrillanceA Flash of Brillance Quick View
    • A Flash of BrillanceA Flash of Brillance Quick View

    • A Flash of Brillance

    • $985.00 $788.00
    • Add to cart
  • A Pod Of ThreeA Pod Of Three Quick View
    • A Pod Of ThreeA Pod Of Three Quick View

    • A Pod Of Three

    • $68.00 $54.40
    • Add to cart
  • An Elegant GestureAn Elegant Gesture Quick View
    • An Elegant GestureAn Elegant Gesture Quick View

    • An Elegant Gesture

    • $825.00 $660.00
    • Add to cart
  • April and SeptemberApril and September Quick View
    • April and SeptemberApril and September Quick View

    • April and September

    • $545.00 $436.00
    • Add to cart
  • Art Deco MaidenArt Deco Maiden Quick View
    • Art Deco MaidenArt Deco Maiden Quick View

    • Art Deco Maiden

    • $120.00 $96.00
    • Add to cart
  • Barabara Bixby BlueBarabara Bixby Blue Quick View
    • Barabara Bixby BlueBarabara Bixby Blue Quick View

    • Barabara Bixby Blue

    • $225.00 $180.00
    • Add to cart
  • Be A GemBe A Gem Quick View
    • Be A GemBe A Gem Quick View

    • Be A Gem

    • $245.00 $196.00
    • Add to cart
  • Black SilkBlack Silk Quick View
    • Black SilkBlack Silk Quick View

    • Black Silk

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue and White DomeBlue and White Dome Quick View
    • Blue and White DomeBlue and White Dome Quick View

    • Blue and White Dome

    • $1,100.00 $880.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue CometBlue Comet Quick View
    • Blue CometBlue Comet Quick View

    • Blue Comet

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue FantasyBlue Fantasy Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Blue FantasyBlue Fantasy Quick View

    • Blue Fantasy

    • $550.00 $440.00
    • Read more
  • Blue FlasherBlue Flasher Quick View
    • Blue FlasherBlue Flasher Quick View

    • Blue Flasher

    • $68.00 $54.40
    • Add to cart
  • Blue HurricaneBlue Hurricane Quick View
    • Blue HurricaneBlue Hurricane Quick View

    • Blue Hurricane

    • $1,995.00 $1,596.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue NestBlue Nest Quick View
    • Blue NestBlue Nest Quick View

    • Blue Nest

    • $950.00 $760.00
    • Add to cart
  • Blue Optical IllusionBlue Optical Illusion Quick View
    • Blue Optical IllusionBlue Optical Illusion Quick View

    • Blue Optical Illusion

    • $1,950.00 $1,560.00
    • Add to cart
  • Bright StarBright Star Quick View
    • Bright StarBright Star Quick View

    • Bright Star

    • $199.00 $159.20
    • Add to cart
  • Bright StarBright Star Quick View
    • Bright StarBright Star Quick View

    • Bright Star

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • Buckle UpBuckle Up Quick View
    • Buckle UpBuckle Up Quick View

    • Buckle Up

    • $1,500.00 $1,200.00
    • Add to cart
  • Call Me AlexCall Me Alex Quick View
    • Call Me AlexCall Me Alex Quick View

    • Call Me Alex

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Candy StripesCandy Stripes Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Candy StripesCandy Stripes Quick View

    • Candy Stripes

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Read more
  • Clear Blue SkyClear Blue Sky Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Clear Blue SkyClear Blue Sky Quick View

    • Clear Blue Sky

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Read more
  • CrimsonCrimson Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      CrimsonCrimson Quick View

    • Crimson

    • $4,150.00 $3,320.00
    • Read more
  • Crown of HeartsCrown of Hearts Quick View
    • Crown of HeartsCrown of Hearts Quick View

    • Crown of Hearts

    • $375.00 $300.00
    • Add to cart
  • Daisy I DoDaisy I Do Quick View
    • Daisy I DoDaisy I Do Quick View

    • Daisy I Do

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • David Yurman Peridot Ring Quick View
    • David Yurman Peridot Ring Quick View

    • David Yurman Peridot Ring

    • $1,450.00 $1,160.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double DelightDouble Delight Quick View
    • Double DelightDouble Delight Quick View

    • Double Delight

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Double VisionDouble Vision Quick View
    • Double VisionDouble Vision Quick View

    • Double Vision

    • $585.00 $468.00
    • Add to cart
  • Earthy SapphireEarthy Sapphire Quick View
    • Earthy SapphireEarthy Sapphire Quick View

    • Earthy Sapphire

    • $575.00 $460.00
    • Add to cart
  • Electric Blue FantasyElectric Blue Fantasy Quick View
    • Electric Blue FantasyElectric Blue Fantasy Quick View

    • Electric Blue Fantasy

    • $775.00 $620.00
    • Add to cart
  • Electromagnetic ProtectionElectromagnetic Protection Quick View
    • Electromagnetic ProtectionElectromagnetic Protection Quick View

    • Electromagnetic Protection

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Emerald EyeEmerald Eye Quick View
    • Emerald EyeEmerald Eye Quick View

    • Emerald Eye

    • $3,500.00 $2,800.00
    • Add to cart
  • Emerald Isle WavesEmerald Isle Waves Quick View
    • Emerald Isle WavesEmerald Isle Waves Quick View

    • Emerald Isle Waves

    • $315.00 $252.00
    • Add to cart
  • Emerald WaveEmerald Wave Quick View
    • Emerald WaveEmerald Wave Quick View

    • Emerald Wave

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • For Your Green Eyes OnlyFor Your Green Eyes Only Quick View
    • For Your Green Eyes OnlyFor Your Green Eyes Only Quick View

    • For Your Green Eyes Only

    • $2,450.00 $1,960.00
    • Add to cart
  • Garnet BurstGarnet Burst Quick View
    • Garnet BurstGarnet Burst Quick View

    • Garnet Burst

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Garnet PrincessGarnet Princess Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Garnet PrincessGarnet Princess Quick View

    • Garnet Princess

    • $335.00 $268.00
    • Read more
  • Garnet Tic Tac Toe Quick View
    • Garnet Tic Tac Toe Quick View

    • Garnet Tic Tac Toe

    • $1,850.00 $1,480.00
    • Add to cart
  • Gemstone DelightGemstone Delight Quick View
    • Gemstone DelightGemstone Delight Quick View

    • Gemstone Delight

    • $225.00 $180.00
    • Add to cart
  • Hail To The QueenHail To The Queen Quick View
    • Hail To The QueenHail To The Queen Quick View

    • Hail To The Queen

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Heartfelt BlessingsHeartfelt Blessings Quick View
    • Heartfelt BlessingsHeartfelt Blessings Quick View

    • Heartfelt Blessings

    • $1,850.00 $1,480.00
    • Add to cart
  • Icy Blue Cascading WaterfallIcy Blue Cascading Waterfall Quick View
    • Icy Blue Cascading WaterfallIcy Blue Cascading Waterfall Quick View

    • Icy Blue Cascading Waterfall

    • $1,250.00 $1,000.00
    • Add to cart
  • Indigo and PeriwinkleIndigo and Periwinkle Quick View
    • Indigo and PeriwinkleIndigo and Periwinkle Quick View

    • Indigo and Periwinkle

    • $199.00 $159.20
    • Add to cart
  • Jade Color SpectrumJade Color Spectrum Quick View
    • Jade Color SpectrumJade Color Spectrum Quick View

    • Jade Color Spectrum

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Jump OversJump Overs Quick View
    • Jump OversJump Overs Quick View

    • Jump Overs

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Add to cart
  • Life ForceLife Force Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Life ForceLife Force Quick View

    • Life Force

    • $635.00 $508.00
    • Read more
  • London BlueLondon Blue Quick View
    • London BlueLondon Blue Quick View

    • London Blue

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • MefkatMefkat Quick View
    • MefkatMefkat Quick View

    • Mefkat

    • $2,450.00 $1,960.00
    • Add to cart
  • Midnight SparklerMidnight Sparkler Quick View
    • Midnight SparklerMidnight Sparkler Quick View

    • Midnight Sparkler

    • $325.00 $260.00
    • Add to cart
  • Moon CraterMoon Crater Quick View
    • Moon CraterMoon Crater Quick View

    • Moon Crater

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Add to cart
  • Musical CherubMusical Cherub Quick View
    • Musical CherubMusical Cherub Quick View

    • Musical Cherub

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • My StarMy Star Quick View
    • My StarMy Star Quick View

    • My Star

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Add to cart
  • Mysterious BlueMysterious Blue Quick View
    • Mysterious BlueMysterious Blue Quick View

    • Mysterious Blue

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Navette BeautyNavette Beauty Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Navette BeautyNavette Beauty Quick View

    • Navette Beauty

    • $695.00 $556.00
    • Read more
  • Off The Heart Beaten PathOff The Heart Beaten Path Quick View
    • Off The Heart Beaten PathOff The Heart Beaten Path Quick View

    • Off The Heart Beaten Path

    • $265.00 $212.00
    • Add to cart
  • Onyx EleganceOnyx Elegance Quick View
    • Onyx EleganceOnyx Elegance Quick View

    • Onyx Elegance

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Onyx Picture FrameOnyx Picture Frame Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Onyx Picture FrameOnyx Picture Frame Quick View

    • Onyx Picture Frame

    • $675.00 $540.00
    • Read more
  • Opal FlockOpal Flock Quick View
    • Opal FlockOpal Flock Quick View

    • Opal Flock

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ornate BambooOrnate Bamboo Quick View
    • Ornate BambooOrnate Bamboo Quick View

    • Ornate Bamboo

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • PartnersPartners Quick View
    • PartnersPartners Quick View

    • Partners

    • $145.00 $116.00
    • Add to cart
  • Peach BlossomPeach Blossom Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Peach BlossomPeach Blossom Quick View

    • Peach Blossom

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Read more
  • PeachyPeachy Quick View
    • PeachyPeachy Quick View

    • Peachy

    • $165.00 $132.00
    • Add to cart
  • Pink Deco BombshellPink Deco Bombshell Quick View
    • Pink Deco BombshellPink Deco Bombshell Quick View

    • Pink Deco Bombshell

    • $6,800.00 $5,440.00
    • Add to cart
  • Pinky TourmalinePinky Tourmaline Quick View
    • Pinky TourmalinePinky Tourmaline Quick View

    • Pinky Tourmaline

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Protect MeProtect Me Quick View
    • Protect MeProtect Me Quick View

    • Protect Me

    • $1,000.00 $800.00
    • Add to cart
  • Purple FlasherPurple Flasher Quick View
    • Purple FlasherPurple Flasher Quick View

    • Purple Flasher

    • $165.00 $132.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red and White DelightRed and White Delight Quick View
    • Red and White DelightRed and White Delight Quick View

    • Red and White Delight

    • $4,850.00 $3,880.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red BowRed Bow Quick View
    • Red BowRed Bow Quick View

    • Red Bow

    • $425.00 $340.00
    • Add to cart
  • Red Daisy DoRed Daisy Do Quick View
    • Red Daisy DoRed Daisy Do Quick View

    • Red Daisy Do

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • Retro BeautyRetro Beauty Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Retro BeautyRetro Beauty Quick View

    • Retro Beauty

    • $975.00 $780.00
    • Read more
  • Retro WavesRetro Waves Quick View
    • Retro WavesRetro Waves Quick View

    • Retro Waves

    • $795.00 $636.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ring Around The OpalRing Around The Opal Quick View
    • Ring Around The OpalRing Around The Opal Quick View

    • Ring Around The Opal

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Royal Blue BeautyRoyal Blue Beauty Quick View
    • Royal Blue BeautyRoyal Blue Beauty Quick View

    • Royal Blue Beauty

    • $7,850.00 $6,280.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby and Diamond Bow TieRuby and Diamond Bow Tie Quick View
    • Ruby and Diamond Bow TieRuby and Diamond Bow Tie Quick View

    • Ruby and Diamond Bow Tie

    • $475.00 $380.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby Pleasure Quick View
    • Ruby Pleasure Quick View

    • Ruby Pleasure

    • $435.00 $348.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby RedRuby Red Quick View
    • Ruby RedRuby Red Quick View

    • Ruby Red

    • $585.00 $468.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby SlipperRuby Slipper Quick View
    • Ruby SlipperRuby Slipper Quick View

    • Ruby Slipper

    • $12,000.00 $9,600.00
    • Add to cart
  • Ruby WaveRuby Wave Quick View
    • Ruby WaveRuby Wave Quick View

    • Ruby Wave

    • $1,200.00 $960.00
    • Add to cart
  • ScarletScarlet Quick View
    • ScarletScarlet Quick View

    • Scarlet

    • $500.00 $400.00
    • Add to cart
  • September’s ChildSeptember’s Child Quick View
    • September’s ChildSeptember’s Child Quick View

    • September’s Child

    • $1,650.00 $1,320.00
    • Add to cart
  • Shield Yourself in PurpleShield Yourself in Purple Quick View
    • Shield Yourself in PurpleShield Yourself in Purple Quick View

    • Shield Yourself in Purple

    • $245.00 $196.00
    • Add to cart
  • Smurf BlueSmurf Blue Quick View
    • Smurf BlueSmurf Blue Quick View

    • Smurf Blue

    • $895.00 $716.00
    • Add to cart
  • Snooty GirlSnooty Girl Quick View
    • Snooty GirlSnooty Girl Quick View

    • Snooty Girl

    • $199.00 $159.20
    • Add to cart
  • Sunset in Sydney Quick View
    • Sunset in Sydney Quick View

    • Sunset in Sydney

    • $7,850.00 $6,280.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tension RelieverTension Reliever Quick View
    • Tension RelieverTension Reliever Quick View

    • Tension Reliever

    • $335.00 $268.00
    • Add to cart
  • The Blushing LadyThe Blushing Lady Quick View
    • The Blushing LadyThe Blushing Lady Quick View

    • The Blushing Lady

    • $199.00 $159.20
    • Add to cart
  • The Coral ReefThe Coral Reef Quick View
    • The Coral ReefThe Coral Reef Quick View

    • The Coral Reef

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • The PeacockThe Peacock Quick View
    • The PeacockThe Peacock Quick View

    • The Peacock

    • $950.00 $760.00
    • Add to cart
  • The TarragonThe Tarragon Quick View
    • The TarragonThe Tarragon Quick View

    • The Tarragon

    • $2,350.00 $1,880.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three AmigosThree Amigos Quick View
    • Three AmigosThree Amigos Quick View

    • Three Amigos

    • $395.00 $316.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three Dimensional StunnerThree Dimensional Stunner Quick View
    • Three Dimensional StunnerThree Dimensional Stunner Quick View

    • Three Dimensional Stunner

    • $2,800.00 $2,240.00
    • Add to cart
  • Three Victorian PodsThree Victorian Pods Quick View
    • Three Victorian PodsThree Victorian Pods Quick View

    • Three Victorian Pods

    • $315.00 $252.00
    • Add to cart
  • Tony The TigerTony The Tiger Quick View
    • Tony The TigerTony The Tiger Quick View

    • Tony The Tiger

    • $78.00 $62.40
    • Add to cart
  • Trichroic BeautyTrichroic Beauty Quick View
    • Trichroic BeautyTrichroic Beauty Quick View

    • Trichroic Beauty

    • $495.00 $396.00
    • Add to cart
  • Trillion CitrineTrillion Citrine Quick View
    • Trillion CitrineTrillion Citrine Quick View

    • Trillion Citrine

    • $295.00 $236.00
    • Add to cart
  • Twinkle Twinkle Red and Blue StarTwinkle Twinkle Red and Blue Star Quick View
    • Twinkle Twinkle Red and Blue StarTwinkle Twinkle Red and Blue Star Quick View

    • Twinkle Twinkle Red and Blue Star

    • $1,650.00 $1,320.00
    • Add to cart
  • Twinkle Twinkle Red StarTwinkle Twinkle Red Star Quick View
    • Twinkle Twinkle Red StarTwinkle Twinkle Red Star Quick View

    • Twinkle Twinkle Red Star

    • $625.00 $500.00
    • Add to cart
  • Victorian TrilogyVictorian Trilogy Quick View
    • Out of Stock
      Victorian TrilogyVictorian Trilogy Quick View

    • Victorian Trilogy

    • $850.00 $680.00
    • Read more
  • VioletViolet Quick View
    • VioletViolet Quick View

    • Violet

    • $2,385.00 $1,908.00
    • Add to cart
  • Virgo and AriesVirgo and Aries Quick View
    • Virgo and AriesVirgo and Aries Quick View

    • Virgo and Aries

    • $595.00 $476.00
    • Add to cart
  • Wing ItWing It Quick View
    • Wing ItWing It Quick View

    • Wing It

    • $299.00 $239.20
    • Add to cart
  • Winged JadeWinged Jade Quick View
    • Winged JadeWinged Jade Quick View

    • Winged Jade

    • $475.00 $380.00
    • Add to cart

Search

Filter by price

Price: —

Product categories

  • Categories: This is how users will find your products on your site
  • Engagement and Wedding
    • Diamond Rings
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Wedding Bands
  • Era
    • Art Deco
    • Art Nouveau
    • Edwardian
    • Estate
    • Midcentury
    • Retro
    • Victorian
  • Merchandise
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Ladies Vanity Items
    • Men's Jewelry
      • Rings
    • Necklaces
    • Pins
    • Rings
      • Diamond Rings
      • Gemstone Rings
    • Silver Jewelry
  • Other

Cart

Facebook Instagram Pinterest

Join Our Newsletter

Facebook Instagram Pinterest

Join Our Newsletter

Facebook Instagram Pinterest

Join Our Newsletter

Navigation

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us

Information

Address:
5459 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221-6730

Phone:
716-633-3738

Email: sarahs_jewelry@verizon.net

Hours
Tuesday-Saturday 11am-4pm

SecurityMetrics Credit Card Safe

Maps

Images provided on this website are for personal, non-commercial use. Republication, retransmission, or reproduction of such images is strictly prohibited.
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Vintage Jewelry
  • Engagement & Wedding
  • Collections
    • Era
      • Art Deco
      • Midcentury
      • Victorian
      • Estate
      • Retro
      • Art Nouveau
      • Edwardian
  • Men’s Jewelry
  • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • Returns & Exchanges
    • Shipping Information
  • 0
  • Toggle website search
Type your search
×
×

Cart